State Ownership vs. Private Enterprise?

0
766 views

State owned operations have a tendency to be bloated and inefficient. Private enterprise puts the shareholder first.

For infrastructure industries such as railways, what is the best option? The privatised UK train network is inefficient, expensive and unreliable, just as it was under government ownership (but the tickets are much more expensive). What are the best options and why?

Infrastructure
Public Sector
Private Sector
David Cottrell
63 months ago

4 answers

0

HYBRID

Government and private partnerships.
Any thoughts?

Dr. David E. M
63 months ago
Been a disaster in the UK. Poorly costed out at the inception and then Government has to bale out the private company - David 63 months ago
No doubt - capitalism is not strong point - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
A private limited company is a business by private owners with liability to their ownership stake, and restricts shareholders from publicly trading shares. In case company runs into a loss, the company shareholders are liable to sell their company shares to clear the debt or liability. The individual or personal assets of shareholders or members are not at risk. - J N Das 63 months ago
Yes - well known - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Bankruptcy laws understood relative to liability - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Government owned companies have important role to control the monopoly created by private companies and keep check on Monopoly Trade Practices. Government owned companies take responsibility for development in underprivileged areas for balanced growth of the whole nation where as private companies not enter in to interior area due to more expenditure and less profit. - Er. Jangyadutta 63 months ago
Yes, Hybrid systems are the right choice. Private to operate and government to control.. - Hitesh 63 months ago
Do not control me - dude = TOTALITARIANISM - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Best view, I appreciate, thanks. - J N Das 63 months ago
Similar - agreed with gratitude - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
0

A government-owned corporation undertakes commercial activities of government which has at least 51% of the paid up share capital is held by government with objectives to achieve more equity in the distribution of income amongst the citizens of the country and to gain the momentum in the growth of the nation.

J N Das
63 months ago
OK - what is the point - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
And delivery of an adequate service - David 63 months ago
Many thanks! - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Govt company obey govt instruction and work to fulfil govt objectives for welfare of citizens even loses faced there. But private company will always look for loss and profit for survival. - J N Das 63 months ago
Yes it is called capitalism Versus Socialism - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Government Owned company does not consider benefit of company as board of Directors politicians and Government l servants give emphasis and interest in pleasing their political party co-workers, Government, Public welfare and less concentrating on growth and development of the company. - Er. Jangyadutta 63 months ago
OK - - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Right it is capitalism vrs socialism, I agree. - J N Das 63 months ago
Often, yes it is - many thanks - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
0

This is not Government’s job to operate a train like services, they mostly fail to provide quality service and to meet the competition . However it’s there job to make all the necessities for an operator to run the train and to govern such operators.

And other options may be including more than one vendors. Like in airlines. However we still need to figure out how to best design a multi vendor model for train like network, and where to invite vendors etc. In private sector best way to control the cost is to create competition.

Hitesh Mathpal
63 months ago
GOVERNMENTS tax PERIOD - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
Yes government has to provide necessary facilities. - J N Das 63 months ago
Define NECESSARY - that is the concern - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
0

In case of necessary situations private companies along with public Companies generating strategic growth for the society and Government Company becomes more required in giving all powers which a private sector company is deprived of and when private companies lack financial arrangement and the objectives are not fulfilled, the private sector joins hands with Government Companies to create effects for growth and expansion.

Er. Jangyadutta D
63 months ago
WOWSA - speachless - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
It good to make government planning to successful partnerships with private company. - J N Das 63 months ago
Hybrid = yes sometimes - others not so much - Dr. David E. 63 months ago

Have some input?