How safe is Probiotics?

0
1937 views

Are there any side effects of Probiotics? What are the natural ways to replace the harmful microbes by useful microbes in our body?

Probiotics development
Microbiology
Pharmaceutical Industry
Genetic Engineering
Biotechnology
microbial fermentation
Food & Beverage
Dietary Supplements
Natural Products
Herbal Remedies
Abhishek Raj
75 months ago

6 answers

1

Although a number of products are available that offer capsules containing mixtures of various bacteria (such as Lactobacillus Acidophilus, Bifidobacterium Bifidum, Streptococcus Thermophilus and Salivarius, Bacillus Coagulans), all appearing to be safe, my preference is to maintain balance of bacteria in my intestine through eating yogurt and various fermented food (much of it made at home).

Karel Petrak
75 months ago
Is there any side effect of these market products? - Abhishek 75 months ago
You can find answers to your questions on probiotics at the following link: https://www.medicinenet.com/probiotics/article.htm#what_are_probiotics - Karel 75 months ago
Thanks Karel. - Abhishek 75 months ago
Another issue is that probiotic products (such as mixtures of various beneficial bacterias) are not approved as “drugs” but are sold as supplements), hence they are not approved / controlled by the FDA. Consequently, there maybe a lack of quality control with these products. Further, proof of efficacy of such products is generally missing... - Karel 75 months ago
Proof of efficacy is very important because I've seen the stability trend of these products and found that most of the brands are quite unstable at accelerated stability studies. - Abhishek 75 months ago
Hokum - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
1

All is a matter of balance between the different probiotic strains. Probiotics are there to help the body but if the balance is not maintained then side effects could occur.

Franck PAVAN
75 months ago
What kind of side effects may occur? - Abhishek 75 months ago
Frank and Abhishek - this link might help give you some more ideas as well. https://nccih.nih.gov/health/probiotics/introduction.htm - James 75 months ago
Thanks James. - Abhishek 75 months ago
Agree - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
1

Abhishek,

The best way to improve microbial balance would be through diet, obviously the consumption of fermented foods helps balance this out, as well as natural fruits and vegetables. The real risks come down to the manufacturer and are they following all the proper food safety strategies. Contamination with pathogenic organisms is always a risk with all raw or unprocessed foodstuffs and beverages, however the innate conditions of many fermented foods prevent pathogens from being present.

The most common side effects (available on a simple online search as well) include gas and bloating as new microbes process your food differently, other possibilities include infections in immunocompromised people and gastrointestinal distress in various forms.

Any shake up of diet can cause temporary or long term issues. Just like if you switched from salads and chicken to fast food or vise versa.

For a quick assessment, I would read this guide on fermented foods to learn more about various safety issues.

https://foodsafety.wisc.edu/assets/pdf_Files/Fermented_Vegetables.pdf

James

James Stephens
75 months ago
thanks for your answer James. - Abhishek 75 months ago
That is a very good summary. Great answer. - Franck 75 months ago
Thank you both! - James 75 months ago
Do a search - Dr. David E. 63 months ago
0

From a food safety perspective, consumers of probiotic products should be concerned about which specific intestinal flora organisms are being introduced into their bodies. The primary questions are: 1) Does the probiotic product list the specific probiotic organisms by name? 2) Will the consumer's digestive system negatively react to the introduction of the specific organisms?
Every human's digestive system can contain up to 10 to the 14th number of bacteria. This bacterial flora is unique to each human being. Maintaining digestive health is key to overall health. Specific, beneficial claims by "health food" products should be carefully considered prior to acceptance and engagement in a dietary regime.

Alvarez, S., Villena, J., & Kitazawa, H. (2014). Probiotics : Immunobiotics and Immunogenics. Boca Raton: CRC Press.
Freitas, A. C., & Silva, J. e. (2014). Probiotic Bacteria : Fundamentals, Therapy, and Technological Aspects. Boca Raton: Pan Stanford.
Preedy, V. R., & Watson, R. R. (2016). Probiotics, Prebiotics, and Synbiotics : Bioactive Foods in Health Promotion. Amsterdam: Academic Press.
Qinghui, M., Jay, K., Christopher M., R., & Xin M., L. (2017). Leaky Gut As a Danger Signal for Autoimmune Diseases. Frontiers In Immunology, Vol 8 (2017), doi:10.3389/fimmu.2017.00598/full

Andy Moreno
75 months ago
Thanks for your answer Andy. - Abhishek 75 months ago
0

Somewhere between 300[9]and 1000 different species live in the gut,[10] with most estimates at about 500.[29][30] However, it is probable that 99% of the bacteria come from about 30 or 40 species, with Faecalibacterium prausnitzii being the most common species in healthy adults.[11][31]
From: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gut_flora

Karel Petrak
75 months ago
Thanks Karel. - Abhishek 75 months ago
0

I think that probiotics generally are safe. However, there are issues with other added ingredients in these supplements. Just as others said, these are not often regulated as well as Rx and you can have all manner of levels of organisms in these pills. Some effective and most not actually. I’m addition, who determines what blend and in what dosage? Do you know what is already there and are targeting or is it a shotgun approach? All important things to consider to not have unintended consequences.

Neal Johnson
75 months ago
The benefits of probiotics in neonates have been well documented in literature (e. g., Michael Sherman et al.). The reason for the FDA not approving probiotic supplements is simply that no product-specific clinical studies showing safety and efficacy have been presented. It is probably more profitable for manufacturers to offer it as supplements... - Karel 75 months ago
Yes I agree with you on efficacy there is no question. I feel like when i comes to Probiotics that say a physician or another medical provider or nutritionist would recommend there should be some reasonable science and demonstrated efficacy so that recommendations will carry more weight. - Neal 75 months ago
I know that the FDA is not “popular”. When I speak as a patient, I want a drug prescribed to me to have a demonstrated efficacy and safety. Probiotics in a form of a capsule filled with “friendly” bacteria may be efficacious and safe, but the existing controls do not guarantee it. To anyone wanting to add probiotics to their diet safely, I suggest eating yogurt and other fermented food. So there. - Karel 75 months ago
Yes but I do believe there are some out there that have demonstrable efficacy and I think they are worth taking a look at as options too. - Neal 75 months ago
In such case, it would be useful to provide a reference to the corresponding documents. - Karel 75 months ago
Here is an interesting reference on probiotic health in obesity - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4761174/ - James 75 months ago
One of many great articles on this topic James. Thanks for posting. - Neal 75 months ago
Thanks for your answers and comments Neal and Karel. You have both shared some valuable inputs on this topic and also the link is very useful. - Abhishek 75 months ago
Significance of bacteria in the human GI has been clearly established. It has been also noted that different compositions of gut bacteria may process food differently so the amount of calories obtained by different individuals from the same food may differ somewhat However, in no way should this be interpreted as bacterial flora being in any way responsible for obesity. - Karel 75 months ago
Thanks Abhishek. Karel think we can all agree there are several causes of obesity but the microbiome has some influence. The Hanza tribe in Tanzania has some interesting dietary habits which when compared by the metric of calories in and calories out makes it a compelling use for microbiome influence. Lots more to be elucidated and i find it fascinating. - Neal 75 months ago

Have some input?